How much is Make a Wish worth?

As of August 2026, Make a Wish from Innistrad has a market value of €0.17. Track price trends and find local trades on Lootstack.

What finishes is Make a Wish available in?

Make a Wish is available in Foil, Nonfoil. Each finish may have a different market value — compare prices for each version on Lootstack.

What set is Make a Wish from?

Make a Wish is from the Innistrad (ISD) expansion, part of the Magic: The Gathering trading card game.

What rarity is Make a Wish?

Make a Wish is a Uncommon card from the Innistrad set in Magic: The Gathering.

What type of card is Make a Wish?

Make a Wish is a Sorcery from the Innistrad set in Magic: The Gathering.

Is Make a Wish legal in Modern?

Make a Wish is Legal in Modern. Check all format legalities for this Magic: The Gathering card on Lootstack.

Make a Wish - Innistrad

Card Availability

See where Make a Wish is available worldwide and at your local stores

Cities

Your Stores

Other printings

View

Legalities

UNKNOWN

Brawl

LEGAL

Commander

LEGAL

Duel

UNKNOWN

Future

UNKNOWN

Frontier

UNKNOWN

Historic

LEGAL

Legacy

LEGAL

Modern

UNKNOWN

Oathbreaker

UNKNOWN

Pauper

LEGAL

Penny

UNKNOWN

Pioneer

UNKNOWN

Standard

LEGAL

Vintage

Foreign Versions

Available in:

Rules & Rulings

9/22/2011

If you only have one card in your graveyard when Make a Wish resolves, that card will be returned to your hand.

9/22/2011

The cards aren’t randomly chosen until Make a Wish resolves.

9/22/2011

Make a Wish isn’t put into its owner’s graveyard until it is finished resolving, so it can’t be returned by its own effect.